W4 vs W2: Understanding the Key Differences and Their Importance

When it comes to US taxes and income reporting, W4 and W2 forms are frequently referenced, yet many don’t fully grasp their differences and significance. Herein, we will outline their distinctions and outline how they might impact your financial position.

girl on laptop

What is a W2 Form?

Employers provide employees with W2 forms annually as the Wage and Tax Statement to provide crucial data about income tax withholdings, financial data for tax year as well as any relevant withholding information for that year. This form can provide key details regarding an employee’s wages, tax withholdings and any relevant financial data for tax season.

Employees use the W2 form to file their income tax return with both the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and state tax authorities. Note: W2 forms are only issued to employees, not independent contractors or freelancers.

What is a W4 Form?

The W4 form, also known as an Employee Withholding Certificate, must be filled out and submitted to their employers when starting a new job or changing tax withholding status. It helps employers determine how much federal income tax to withhold from employees’ paychecks.

Employees can change the information on their W4 form to adjust the amount of taxes withheld from their paychecks, according to their individual needs and tax situation. For example, those claiming multiple deductions and tax credits might opt to have less withheld, while if their tax liability exceeds expectations they might choose more withholding to avoid being subject to large tax bills at tax time.

The Key Differences Between W4 and W2 Forms

Now that we have an understanding of W4 and W2 forms, let’s delve deeper into their main differences:

  1. Purpose: The W4 form is used to calculate the correct federal income tax withholding amount from an employee’s paycheck; its counterpart, W2, reports their annual income and tax withholdings to both IRS and state authorities.
  2. Timing: Employees typically complete a W4 form upon beginning employment or updating their withholding status, and their employers provide it annually (by January 31st) to employees.
  3. Recipient: Employees submit the W4 form directly to their employers while employers give out W2 forms directly to employees and submit them directly to IRS and state tax authorities.
  4. Adjustments: Employees are free to make adjustments to their W4 form at any point during the year, which will impact their future tax withholdings. On the other hand, information on W2 forms are fixed and any discrepancies must be corrected by employers immediately.

How to Fill Out a W4 Form

Filling out a W4 form requires careful consideration of both your financial status and tax obligations. Here are some steps that may help guide you through this process:

  1. Personal Information: Provide your full name, Social Security number, address and filing status (such as single, married, head of household etc).
  2. Multiple Jobs or Spouse Works: If you have multiple jobs or both you and your spouse work, the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator could be useful in calculating an accurate withholding amount.
  3. Claim Dependents: List any dependents you have, such as children or other qualifying relatives, and calculate any associated tax credits.
  4. Other Adjustments: If you plan to itemize deductions or claim other forms of income adjustments, such as credits and rebates, then your W4 form should include this information.
  5. Sign and Date: Once complete, sign and date it before giving it to your employer.

Remember, you can adjust your W4 form at any time if your financial or tax situation changes.

W4 Form 2023

How to Read a W2 Form

Once you receive your W2 form, it is essential to understand its contents. Here’s a brief run-down of its most crucial sections:

  1. Box 1: This section displays your total taxable wages, tips and compensation for the tax year.
  2. Box 2: This section shows the total federal income tax withheld from your paycheck during the tax year.
  3. Box 3 & 5: These sections display your total wages subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes, respectively.
  4. Box 4 & 6: These sections detail the total amount withheld for Social Security and Medicare taxes from your paychecks over the course of this tax year.
  5. Box 12: This section offers information on various benefits and compensation, such as contributions to retirement plans or health savings accounts (HSA).
  6. Box 16: This section displays your total state-taxable wages.
  7. Box 17: This section shows the total state income tax withheld from your paycheck during the tax year.

2023 W2 form

By understanding the information on your W2 form, you can ensure that your tax return is complete and accurate.

Understanding the difference between W4 and W2 forms is of vital importance to both employees and employers alike. While W4 forms help employers determine appropriate tax withholding from an employee’s paycheck, while W2 forms serve as a comprehensive overview of an employee’s income and tax withholdings for an entire tax year.

As an employee, it’s vitally important that you review and update your W4 form regularly in order to ensure accurate withholding, and review your W2 form for any discrepancies or anomalies. By staying aware of these tax forms and their implications, you can better manage your financial situation and avoid unexpected tax liabilities.


Can I change my W4 form at any time during the year?

Yes, your W4 form should be updated as often as needed; however, before making significant modifications it would be prudent to consult with a tax professional first as this can impact your final tax liability at year’s end.

Do I need to fill out a new W4 form for each job?

Yes, it is essential that you complete a W4 form for every employer in order to ensure accurate withholding for every job. Since income levels and tax implications differ for different jobs, providing accurate information for every employer is paramount.

What should I do if I notice a mistake on my W2 form?

If you find any discrepancies on your W2 form, be sure to inform your employer as soon as possible in order to request an updated one. They are responsible for correcting any mistakes on it before issuing an updated W2 to both yourself and tax authorities.

What happens if I don’t submit a W4 form to my employer?

If you do not provide your employer with a W4 form, they are required to withhold taxes at their default rate which could result in too much being withheld from each paycheck and potentially leading to an unnecessary tax refund come April. To prevent this situation from occurring, it’s wiser to complete and submit a W4 form as soon as possible.

Are independent contractors required to fill out W4 or W2 forms?

Independent contractors and freelancers do not fall under the definition of employees; therefore they do not require filling out W4 forms and receiving W2 forms from their clients as evidence of income for tax purposes. Instead, clients typically provide them with Form 1099-NEC to report their income for tax reporting.

Leave a Comment